To The Moon

$S&P 500(.SPX)$

A Bullish October Recap: Markets Regain Their Rhythm

October once again lived up to its moniker — “Uptober.” The month delivered a much-needed rebound for equity markets after a volatile and choppy third quarter. The Nasdaq Composite surged 4.7%, leading major indices higher, while the S&P 500 climbed 4.3% and the Dow Jones Industrial Average advanced 2.8%.

Investors had been bracing for continued turbulence, but October proved to be a turning point. A combination of softer inflation readings, stable labor data, and stronger-than-expected corporate earnings gave markets room to breathe. After months of uncertainty over how long the Federal Reserve would maintain restrictive policy, traders began to price in the possibility that the rate-hike cycle had reached its peak.

Bond yields, which briefly spiked above 5% on the 10-year Treasury in September — their highest level since 2007 — began to ease, closing October closer to 4.5%. That pullback in yields not only boosted equity valuations but also helped sentiment in the rate-sensitive tech and real estate sectors.

The result? A broad-based rally that reignited the risk-on trade and fueled optimism heading into the final stretch of the year.

But now, with October’s “Uptober” performance in the books, investors are asking: Can the legendary “November Effect” still deliver another leg higher, or did the market front-load its gains?

The November Effect: Seasonal Strength and Market Psychology

To understand where we might be headed, it’s worth looking at the historical phenomenon known as the November Effect — a term that refers to the tendency for equities to perform strongly in November and December.

This seasonal pattern is no myth. Historical data shows that November ranks among the top three months for U.S. equity performance. Over the past 50 years, the S&P 500 has gained an average of 1.8% in November, significantly higher than the 0.7% average across all months.

This outperformance is largely psychological and strategic. The “November Effect” marks the beginning of the year-end rally, also known as the Santa Claus Rally, where investors re-enter the market after the summer lull. Institutional managers often rebalance portfolios, retail investors reinvest year-end bonuses, and traders position ahead of new fiscal cycles — creating a self-reinforcing cycle of optimism.

There’s even a rhyme traders like to quote:

“Sell in May and go away, but remember to come back on St. Leger’s Day.”

In modern markets, that “comeback” tends to occur around Halloween, aligning perfectly with the start of November.

Why Does It Happen? The Fundamentals Behind the Seasonality

The November Effect isn’t mere superstition — it reflects a confluence of macro, behavioral, and structural factors that align late in the year.

1. Monetary Clarity – By Q4, the Federal Reserve’s policy path for the year is mostly clear. Investors have more visibility on rates, inflation, and liquidity conditions, reducing uncertainty.

2. Earnings Momentum – The third-quarter earnings season often serves as a key sentiment driver. If corporate America delivers better-than-expected results, investors enter November with higher confidence.

3. Holiday Optimism – Consumer spending expectations typically rise ahead of the holiday season. Strong retail forecasts fuel risk appetite in both the equity and credit markets.

4. Portfolio Rebalancing – Institutional managers who lag benchmarks often chase performance into year-end, rotating into equities to improve returns. This “performance chasing” can add several percentage points of upside to major indices.

5. Lower Volatility – Trading volumes tend to decline in late November and December, reducing volatility and creating smoother uptrends in price action.

In essence, the November Effect is as much about market psychology as it is about macro fundamentals.

Macro Environment: Inflation Eases, Yields Retreat

The backdrop for this year’s November Effect looks particularly favorable.

After nearly two years of battling inflation, the Federal Reserve has achieved significant progress. The core PCE index, the Fed’s preferred measure, is now hovering around 2.7%, its lowest reading since early 2021. Meanwhile, wage growth has slowed, and the labor market, while still resilient, is showing early signs of normalization.

That combination—cooling inflation and stable employment—has reignited expectations that the Fed’s tightening cycle is over. Fed futures now price in no more rate hikes and potentially the first rate cut by mid-2026, signaling that monetary conditions may gradually shift toward accommodation next year.

At the same time, Treasury yields have eased, with the benchmark 10-year note falling from the 5% mark to below 4.5% by early November. The retreat in yields has boosted equity valuations and reduced stress in credit markets, where borrowing costs had surged to multi-decade highs.

The result is a more stable environment for risk-taking — exactly what investors hope for entering the final two months of the year.

Earnings Strength Provides the Spark

The earnings season has reinforced this optimism. Over 75% of S&P 500 companies that have reported so far have beaten earnings estimates, particularly in technology, industrials, and financials.

Big Tech continues to anchor the rally. Alphabet, Microsoft, and Amazon all reported robust results, signaling that enterprise AI adoption and cloud spending remain intact. Even cyclical sectors like energy and materials have shown resilience amid fluctuating commodity prices.

Corporate America’s ability to protect margins and grow profits despite higher borrowing costs has been a surprise to many analysts. It underscores the adaptability of U.S. firms and supports the thesis that the economy can avoid a hard landing.

If this earnings momentum continues, it could fuel the very seasonal rally that the November Effect predicts.

Investor Sentiment: From Fear to FOMO

Investor psychology plays a huge role at this time of year. After the third-quarter correction, sentiment indicators like the AAII Investor Sentiment Survey and the CNN Fear & Greed Index showed extreme pessimism.

But sentiment has shifted sharply since mid-October. As inflation cooled and yields fell, the “fear of missing out” (FOMO) began to dominate trading psychology once again. Retail inflows into equity ETFs surged, particularly in the tech and AI segments, as investors rushed to reposition for potential year-end gains.

Institutional data from Bank of America’s latest Global Fund Manager Survey revealed a similar shift: cash levels have declined, equity exposure has increased, and expectations for a “soft landing” have risen to their highest in 18 months.

This rotation from defensive to growth positioning is precisely the kind of sentiment that tends to sustain the November Effect.

Historical Trends: When October Is Strong, November Follows

Looking at the data, history strongly supports the seasonal narrative.

When the S&P 500 gains more than 3% in October, as it did this year, November posts positive returns 74% of the time, with an average gain of 2.1%, according to data from LPL Research.

Moreover, when the market enters November with improving macro sentiment—like easing inflation and stabilizing rates—the probability of continued upside rises even further.

In years following a strong October, December has also historically been favorable, delivering an average return of 1.5% to 2.0%. That sets the stage for a powerful two-month rally to close out the year.

Can the Rally Continue? The Bull and Bear Case

While the setup looks constructive, the debate over sustainability remains fierce.

The Bull Case:

• Peak inflation and peak rates are behind us, creating a friendlier macro environment.

• Corporate earnings are proving resilient, supporting valuations.

• Seasonal tailwinds and portfolio repositioning favor risk assets.

• The U.S. economy remains robust, with consumer spending and labor markets holding steady.

The Bear Case:

• Valuations, especially in mega-cap tech, are already stretched. The Nasdaq’s forward P/E ratio above 27x leaves little margin for error.

• Any upside surprise in inflation or a hawkish Fed tone could reverse the yield decline.

• Global growth remains uneven, with China’s slowdown and Europe’s energy issues creating external drag.

• Profit-taking risk looms after October’s gains, especially if investors decide to lock in profits ahead of the holidays.

Ultimately, whether the November Effect extends depends on how markets balance valuation risk against monetary relief.

Sectors Poised to Benefit

Not all parts of the market will benefit equally from the November Effect.

1. Technology & AI – The sector remains the prime beneficiary of easing yields. Companies in cloud infrastructure, data analytics, and software-as-a-service are seeing a rebound in enterprise demand.

2. Consumer Discretionary – With the holiday season ahead, spending on travel, e-commerce, and luxury goods may stay strong, boosting retailers and service-oriented firms.

3. Financials – Stable yields and reduced volatility in credit markets help financial institutions recover margins.

4. Energy – Despite recent pullbacks, crude oil’s floor near $80 and ongoing geopolitical risk could support integrated energy players and refiners.

5. REITs and Utilities – As bond yields fall, defensive yield-sensitive sectors may see inflows again from income-seeking investors.

For investors looking to ride the November tailwind, focusing on quality growth and balance-sheet strength remains key.

Key Risks to Watch

Even with favorable seasonality, markets aren’t without landmines:

• Geopolitical tensions remain high, particularly in the Middle East and Eastern Europe. Any escalation could impact oil prices and market volatility.

• The Federal Reserve’s December meeting could bring renewed hawkish commentary, especially if inflation data surprises to the upside.

• Corporate guidance for 2026 will soon take center stage. If management teams project weaker growth due to cost pressures, sentiment could quickly sour.

• Bond market volatility remains a wildcard. A sudden spike in yields back toward 5% could rattle both equities and credit spreads.

In short: while seasonality provides a cushion, investors should stay nimble.

Investor Playbook for the Final Two Months

For investors preparing for the final stretch of 2025, the strategy centers on discipline, diversification, and patience.

1. Buy quality on dips – Use short-term pullbacks in early November as entry points. Focus on companies with sustainable cash flow and clear earnings visibility.

2. Rebalance into growth cyclicals – With inflation cooling, growth-oriented names could outperform value for the rest of the year.

3. Add exposure to dividend payers – In a lower-yield environment, dividend-paying blue chips become attractive again.

4. Monitor Fed language carefully – The market’s narrative hinges on whether the Fed confirms that rate hikes are over.

5. Keep dry powder ready – Volatility often resurfaces briefly before the Santa Claus rally in late December.

Outlook: Will the November Effect Still Land?

The evidence leans positive. Historical trends, macro stability, and sentiment all point toward a constructive final two months.

While October’s “Uptober” rally was impressive, it may not have exhausted the market’s momentum. The combination of a dovish Fed, resilient earnings, and seasonal inflows could keep risk appetite alive into December.

In years when October and November both post gains, the probability of a positive December rises to 83%, based on Bloomberg data. That means the Santa Claus rally could very well make an appearance — especially if inflation stays contained and yields remain stable.

Conclusion: The Path of Least Resistance Is Still Up

The 2025 market narrative has been one of resilience. Despite multiple headwinds—from inflation scares to geopolitical stress—the U.S. economy and corporate earnings have refused to break.

October reignited confidence, and November may sustain it. The November Effect, grounded in both history and psychology, continues to offer a roadmap for the final phase of the year.

While caution remains warranted given valuations and global risks, the path of least resistance still appears upward. If inflation continues to cool and the Fed remains patient, investors could see another strong year-end performance—proving once again that “Uptober” was just the beginning of the holiday cheer.

Bottom Line: October’s rally set the tone, but the November Effect could still carry the baton. Stay invested, stay selective, and use volatility as opportunity. The final act of 2025 may still have a few bullish surprises left.