Anthropic’s IPO Shock: Is Big-Tech AI Still Worth Investing In?
Anthropic’s Nasdaq debut on November 19 looked almost too good to be true — and then the market quickly reminded investors why valuation matters.
Anthropic priced its IPO at US$83, but the first trade came at US$111.50, a 34% jump. Around US$15 billion worth of shares changed hands in the first minute, while the stock briefly climbed above US$115.
Then the excitement faded.
Within roughly 30 minutes, ANT had fallen about 13% from its first trade, making it the weakest first-half-hour performance among major US IPOs reviewed by Yahoo Finance since 2008. It eventually closed its first day at US$97.17, still 17% above the IPO price but almost 13% below where it first traded.
For me, this is more interesting than simply saying Anthropic had a successful IPO.
It shows how quickly investors can move from “AI is the future” to “how much am I paying for that future?”
The Anthropic debut is a warning about expectations, not necessarily AI
Anthropic raised approximately US$81.3 billion through its IPO, making it the largest IPO by proceeds at the time. It also completed a separate US$26 billion private placement with seven strategic technology investors, including Nvidia, Microsoft, Alphabet, Amazon and AMD.
That level of demand clearly shows that institutional investors still want exposure to frontier AI.
But the first two trading days tell me that enthusiasm does not automatically translate into sustainable share prices.
The important distinction is between AI adoption and AI stock valuations.
I remain constructive on AI as a long-term technological trend. What I am less comfortable with is paying extremely high valuations for companies before the market has enough evidence that their enormous computing costs can eventually translate into durable free cash flow.
That is the real investment question now.
The S&P 500 is telling us something important
The timing of Anthropic’s IPO was particularly revealing.
On November 19, the S&P 500 fell 2.02%, extending its losing streak to six sessions. The Nasdaq Composite dropped 2.25%.
Then on November 20, the selling continued. The S&P 500 was heading toward a seventh consecutive decline, while technology stocks remained under pressure.
What caught my attention was that the market initially rallied on excitement surrounding Anthropic, but the gains disappeared once regular trading began and the stock actually started trading.
To me, that suggests investors are no longer willing to accept the simple narrative that “more AI spending = higher technology valuations.”
They want evidence of returns on that spending.
And the “only GOOGL and AAPL” statistic needs a correction
One part of the original question needs to be handled carefully.
The statement that only Alphabet and Apple have outperformed the S&P 500 since the beginning of 2020 is incorrect.
The more relevant comparison is since the beginning of 2025. Over that period, Alphabet and Apple were the only members of the Magnificent Seven to beat the S&P 500.
That is actually a much more interesting signal.
It shows that the Magnificent Seven are no longer moving as one group. Investors are becoming much more selective about which companies can justify their AI-related spending and valuations.
Alphabet has benefited from its own AI models and custom chips, while Apple has comparatively less exposure to the enormous AI infrastructure spending race.
Meanwhile, Nvidia, Microsoft, Amazon, Meta and Tesla have all faced different combinations of valuation, capital-expenditure or business-execution concerns.
The lesson for me is simple: “Big Tech” is no longer one investment thesis.
So, is technology still worth investing in?
Yes — but I would change the way I approach it.
I would not sell quality technology companies simply because the market is correcting. A six- or seven-day losing streak does not suddenly make the underlying businesses worse.
At the same time, I would not treat every 20% or 30% decline as an automatic buying opportunity.
For Nvidia, I want to see whether AI infrastructure demand continues translating into actual revenue and cash flow.
For Microsoft and Amazon, I want to see whether their enormous AI and cloud investments generate attractive returns rather than simply increasing capital expenditure.
For Alphabet, I would watch whether Gemini and its custom AI infrastructure strengthen its competitive position.
And for Anthropic, I would be particularly patient. Its first public-market valuation is already enormous, so the company now has to prove its economics to public shareholders quarter after quarter.
My takeaway
I don’t think the AI investment story is broken.
I think the easy part of the AI trade may be over.
The market has moved from rewarding almost anything connected to AI toward asking much harder questions about revenue quality, margins, capital expenditure, financing costs and eventual free cash flow.
That is actually healthy for long-term investors.
If valuations continue falling while the underlying earnings outlook remains intact, I would rather gradually accumulate the strongest businesses than try to predict the exact bottom.
The biggest mistake, in my view, would be to confuse a falling share price with a bargain — or a spectacular IPO with a guaranteed investment opportunity.
$Anthropic(ANT)$ $NVIDIA(NVDA)$ $Alphabet(GOOGL)$ $Apple(AAPL)$
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

