Nvidia Falls, AMD Surges, Then Everything Reverses! Is the AI Rally Breaking Down?
Comrades, something unusual happened on Wall Street.
On Wednesday, November 18:
π QQQ gained 0.39%.
π AMD surged 5.31%.
π Broadcom rallied 3.64%.
π Nvidia dropped 2.89%, despite delivering blockbuster earnings.
It looked as though investors were rotating from the AI giant into its competitors.
Then Thursday arrived.
The Nasdaq plunged 2.25%, Nvidia fell another 3.3%, AMD dropped 7.7%, and Broadcom lost 2.1%.
One day's AI winners became the next day's casualties.
And that tells me something important.
The market isn't necessarily abandoning artificial intelligence. But it is becoming much less willing to pay any price for AI growth.
Here's why I think the next few trading sessions matter.
π₯ 1. Nvidia's Earnings Were Excellent. The Stock Wasn't.
Nvidia's latest quarter delivered:
π° Revenue: $115.8 billion
π» Data Center revenue: $107.6 billion
π Next-quarter guidance: $130 billion Β±3%
Those are extraordinary figures.
Yet Nvidia declined for six consecutive sessions through November 19.
Here's the contradiction.
The business is generating exceptional revenue, but investors are increasingly concerned about valuation, future margins, leadership uncertainty and the enormous spending required to sustain AI growth.
The $130 billion guidance also includes an additional reporting week, while projected non-GAAP gross margins fall to approximately 71%β72%.
That doesn't mean Nvidia's competitive advantage has disappeared.
It means earnings expectations and valuation expectations are two different things.
A company can beat earnings and still disappoint investors who were expecting perfection.
π 2. Why AMD and Broadcom Initially Rallied
Wednesday's price action suggested investors were becoming more interested in alternative AI infrastructure suppliers.
AMD has growing opportunities in AI accelerators.
Broadcom benefits from custom AI chips and networking.
Both could gain business as major cloud customers diversify their computing infrastructure.
But here's where I disagree with the most optimistic interpretation.
A rising AMD share price alongside a falling Nvidia share price does not prove customers are transferring chip orders.
Stock prices reflect positioning, sentiment, valuation and expectations.
Actual customer orders take time to develop, deliver and recognise as revenue.
And Thursday demonstrated how quickly that optimism can disappear.
AMD's reversal was amplified by a short-seller report concerning its exposure to China.
That was a company-specific development, not proof that AI demand had suddenly collapsed.
Broadcom and Micron also declined as broader selling intensified.
My interpretation?
Investors are trying to identify the next AI winners, but the entire sector remains vulnerable to changes in risk appetite.
βοΈ 3. Anthropic's Record IPO Didn't Save the Market
Another major event occurred Thursday.
Anthropic priced its IPO at $83 per share, above the original indicative range.
Its shares opened at $111.50 and briefly reached $115.
Incredible demand!
But by the closing bell, the shares had surrendered much of their initial premium, finishing approximately 17% above the IPO price.
Meanwhile, the Nasdaq fell more than 2%.
This matters.
A successful IPO can attract fresh interest in AI, but it can also absorb capital from investors who sell existing holdings to participate.
And strong demand for one newly listed company doesn't guarantee an immediate rally across technology stocks.
The next AI rally needs broader buying participation, not just excitement around one headline.
π― 4. My QQQ Prediction: November 20β27
After Wednesday's $659.51 close, QQQ retreated towards $650 on Thursday.
Here are my scenarios for the coming trading sessions.
π’ Bull Case: 25%
QQQ: $660β$675
Technology stocks stabilise, Nvidia recovers, and AMD and Broadcom regain momentum.
A sustained reclaim of $660, followed by $665 with stronger participation, would increase my confidence.
π‘ Base Case: 45%
QQQ: $640β$660
This is my most likely scenario.
I expect sharp relief rallies, failed breakouts and continued disagreement between investors about AI valuations.
Some stocks may recover, but the broader market remains choppy.
π΄ Bear Case: 30%
QQQ: $615β$640
Selling accelerates as investors reduce exposure to expensive technology stocks.
Hawkish Federal Reserve expectations, weaker semiconductor sentiment or another disappointing AI-related announcement could deepen the correction.
These probabilities are my judgment-based scenarios, not statistically validated forecasts.
My prediction? A convincing, broad-based technology recovery is less likely than continued volatility over the next several sessions.
π° 5. What Would Convince Me to Buy?
I'm watching four signals.
1. QQQ must reclaim $660.
A recovery towards $660β$665 would improve the immediate technical picture.
But I want the breakout to hold, not simply produce another opening spike.
2. Nvidia needs to stop making new lows.
A sustained move back above $150β$155 would be an early sign of stabilisation.
I'd become more constructive if momentum subsequently recovered towards $160β$165.
3. Semiconductor participation must improve.
I want to see Nvidia, AMD, Broadcom and Micron showing strength together.
If QQQ rises while the semiconductor index continues falling, I would question the rally's durability.
4. Market breadth must improve.
On Thursday, declining Nasdaq stocks outnumbered advancing stocks by more than three to one.
That's not the kind of participation I want to see in a healthy recovery.
A stronger rally should involve more than a handful of heavyweight stocks.
π§ 6. What Most Investors Are Missing
I think the AI trade is entering a different phase.
Previously, investors rewarded companies simply for announcing enormous AI spending, partnerships or infrastructure expansion.
Now they're asking harder questions.
Will that spending generate sufficient profits?
Can customers afford their commitments?
Will margins improve or deteriorate?
Which companies have genuine competitive advantages, rather than just attractive stories?
And perhaps most importantly:
Which stocks already have too much future success reflected in their valuations?
That's why I don't think buying every semiconductor dip is the right strategy.
Nvidia can remain the industry leader.
AMD can continue gaining customers.
Broadcom can expand custom silicon revenue.
Micron can benefit from rising memory demand.
All four businesses may grow while their share prices struggle during a sector-wide valuation reset.
π‘ My Final Take: Is QQQ Ready to Rally?
I'm not abandoning the long-term AI investment thesis.
But I'm becoming more selective about when to trade it.
My base case is QQQ fluctuating between $640 and $660, with a stronger recovery requiring convincing participation across semiconductor stocks.
For now, I'd rather preserve capital and watch for a sustainable recovery than chase one-day rallies.
The next opportunity may not come from predicting which AI company has the best earnings. It may come from recognising when institutional buyers are finally willing to support those earnings again.
That's the difference between a temporary bounce and a genuine market recovery.
Comrades, which would you choose now?
Nvidia after its decline, AMD and Broadcom after their volatile moves, or QQQ for broader technology exposure?
I am not a financial advisor. Trade wisely, Comrades!
If you find this post interesting, give it wings! πͺ½ Repost and share the insights. Do consider βFollow meβ and get firsthand read of my daily new post. Thank you.
@TigerPM @TigerStars @Daily_Discussion @TigerEvents @Tiger_SG
Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.
- GregoryRichardsonΒ·11-20 10:53QQQ gets my vote here. Post-earnings valuation digestion can keep institutions cautious even while chip demand holds up; strong results don't guarantee immediate buyingLikeReport
