OBDC's Price Implies A 12% Loan Loss. Only 1% Have Stopped Paying.

Mathematical Money | November 19, 2026


Three things get said about private credit lenders this month, and each one has a number that tests it. I ran the tests on two of them, Blue Owl Capital Corp (OBDC) and FS KKR Capital (FSK). The inputs are their own third-quarter releases and Wednesday's Tiger closes.


"Only a few percent of the loans are bad"


Both figures are accurate as far as they go. Blue Owl has 0.8% of its loans on non-accrual, meaning they have stopped paying interest. At FS KKR it is 3.4%.


Look at the same figure measured at cost and you see what the lenders have already done. Blue Owl is at 2.9% and FS KKR at 6.4%. The loans were bought at one price and are now marked at far less, so some of the damage is in the books already.


Now the price. Blue Owl's stock closed at $10.67, against a net asset value of $14.32. That is 25% below. FS KKR sits 39% below its $18.28.


Here is how I turn a discount into a loan loss. Take the discount and multiply it by the net assets. Then divide by the total loans the lender holds.


For Blue Owl, 25% of its net assets is about $1.8 billion. Spread over its $15.1 billion of loans, that is 12%. FS KKR works out at 17%.


That is what the discount would mean if it were all credit losses. Today 0.8% and 3.4% of the loans have stopped paying, so the price asks for five to fifteen times as much.


The inputs are the share price, the net asset value per share, net assets and total loans. They sit on the first pages of any lender's quarterly release, and the sum takes a minute. Run it on a fund you own, and if the answer is many times the non-accrual rate, you are being asked to believe something the release does not show.


"A discount that big has to be a bargain"


The discount has two parts, and only one is about credit.


The first part is leverage. Both lenders hold a little over two dollars of loans for every dollar of net assets. A 1% loss on the loans costs about 2% of the equity, so the rule of thumb is to double it.


The second part is trust in the marks. Net asset value is the manager's own estimate of what the loans are worth. The share price is what strangers will pay. When the two sit 25% to 39% apart, strangers are saying that the estimate is too high, or that more loans are about to go wrong.


Trade press has started calling the harder cases "shadow defaults", loans that were amended so they never show up as non-accrual. I cannot see those in a release. So a low non-accrual figure and a large implied loss can both be right.


"The managers are buying back stock, so they think it's cheap"


FS KKR bought about six million shares in the quarter at an average of $11.24. In October it bought another 1.5 million at $10.88. That buys a dollar of reported net asset value for about 61 cents.


If the marks are right, that is very good for the shares that remain. If they are wrong, the company is using cash and borrowing to buy loans it already owns. Its net debt to equity went from 122% to 125% in the quarter.


Blue Owl bought back $35 million of stock, and its leverage edged up a little. Both facts fit either story. A buyback shows what management believes, and it can't tell you whether they are right.


My view


I own none of these, and I am not telling anyone to buy or sell them. What the test shows is narrower. Both prices ask for loss rates far above anything the lenders report, and nobody outside the loan books can tell which side is wrong.


On the next reports I would check two things. First, whether non-accruals at cost keep rising while net asset value holds steady, which would mean the marks are lagging. Second, whether either lender keeps buying back stock while leverage climbs.


The number I most want and cannot get is how many loans were amended to avoid showing up as bad.


Sources: Blue Owl's and FS KKR's third-quarter 8-K press releases, Tiger closes on 18 November. The 12%, 17% and the 61 cents are my own arithmetic from those figures.


$OBDC$ $FSK$

#privatecredit #BDC #credit #dividends #investing

Disclaimer: Investing carries risk. This is not financial advice. The above content should not be regarded as an offer, recommendation, or solicitation on acquiring or disposing of any financial products, any associated discussions, comments, or posts by author or other users should not be considered as such either. It is solely for general information purpose only, which does not consider your own investment objectives, financial situations or needs. TTM assumes no responsibility or warranty for the accuracy and completeness of the information, investors should do their own research and may seek professional advice before investing.

Report

Comment(1)

  • Top
  • Latest
  • Mess0M
    ·11-20 11:23
    25% below NAV looks overly pessimistic to me. OBDC buying back shares strengthens the value case, provided dividend coverage holds up
    Reply
    Report